Where To Get The Best Ice Cream In The Hamptons

Catherine Doolan

Summer is officially here and that means it is ice cream time! Here are a few of the best places to devour ice cream in The Hamptons on a hot summer day.

Shock Ice Cream - Westhampton Beach, NY

Shock Ice Cream is located on Main Street in Westhampton Beach. It is most well known for its “Carnival Cone” which is an ice cream cone with your flavor of choice, wrapped in cotton candy. Shock is offering delivery and curbside pickup for all of your favorite flavors. The ice cream shop also sells face masks!

Gemelli Gelato - Hampton Bays, NY

Gemelli Gelato can be found on Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays. Gemelli offers a variety of flavors including dairy free flavors. They are also well known for their flavored waffle cones. Gemelli Gelato is now open for in person shopping (face mask required) and delivery.

Graham Central Station is our New Flavor for the Weekend! Everyone keeps asking what's in it, what does it taste like, I saw the video of it being made, what were all the pieces? Watch our Instagram Story to find out some of the facts about Graham Central Station! It's very flavor full and delicious! 🍓 Our new lawn signs are really working great. Everyone is sending in so many photos. We can't wait to repost them daily. Thank you so much for tagging us. Be sure to Tag us @gemelli_gelato 📸 @avaschumm & @sophia_schumm Thank you for the Gelato perfect picture! Hope to see you again soon! 🍧 WEEKEND FEATURED FLAVORS 🌞BLUEBERRY BASIL WIL BE BACK BY POPULAR DEMAND 🚂Graham Central Station 🍋🍋Lemon Cookie 🍨As always, Stay Safe, Stay Healthy & Be Smart. ⛱ #thehamptons #longisland #suffolk #eastend #southampton #westhampton #bridgehampton #hamptonsocial #nassau #easthampton #longislandeastend #longislandfoodie #longislandicecream #gelato #gemelli_gelato #news12li #news12eastend #1061wbli #hamptonshouse #hamptonsstyle #hamptonsliving #hamptonssummer #hamptonsart #hamptonsweekend #hamptonsevents #hamptonsphotographer #hamptonsny #hamptonscaterer #hamptonseats

 Buddhaberry Frozen Yogurt - Sag Harbor, NY

Calling all frozen yogurt lovers! Buddhaberry frozen yogurt in Sag Harbor is the place for you. Buddhaberry offers fresh daily flavors that you can top with nutritional toppings that taste delicious. Buddhaberry also sells coffee,  acai bowls, smoothies, shakes, crepes, and waffles.

Hello August 🌸 #thebuddhaberry #frozenyogurt #matcha #summer #sagharbor

 The Fudge Company - Southampton, NY

The Fudge Company in Southampton has every type of ice cream that you could want! From hard frozen yogurt to soft frozen yogurt, non-fat options, sherberts, and sugar free items, The Fudge Company has you covered. Alongside their ice cream, The Fudge Company is well known for their homemade fudge.

2026 Update: What’s New at These Hamptons Favorites

Shock Ice Cream at 99 Main Street in Westhampton Beach celebrated 25 years in 2025, and founder Elyse Richman has kept adding to the menu, from the famous Carnival Cone to Dubai chocolate sundaes and vegan soft serve, according to Dan’s Papers. BuddhaBerry, long a Sag Harbor staple, also added a second location on Hampton Road in Southampton Village, as reported by 27east. Many Hamptons sweet shops keep shorter hours outside of summer, so check before you go. Making a day of it? Pair your cone with one of our favorite outdoor dining spots in the Hamptons.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can you get the best ice cream in the Hamptons?

Our picks are Shock Ice Cream in Westhampton Beach, Gemelli Gelato in Hampton Bays, BuddhaBerry in Sag Harbor and Southampton, and The Fudge Company in Southampton.

What is Shock Ice Cream known for?

Shock is best known for its Carnival Cone, topped with cotton candy, edible glitter and sugar emojis. The menu also includes spaghetti sundaes, vegan soft serve and no-sugar-added options.

Where is Gemelli Gelato in Hampton Bays?

Gemelli Gelato is at 139 West Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays.

Does BuddhaBerry have more than one Hamptons location?

Yes. In addition to its longtime Sag Harbor shop, BuddhaBerry opened a location on Hampton Road in Southampton Village.

Birthday cake is back!

Have a listing you think should be featured contact us or email at Jeremy@offthemrkt.com to tell us more! Follow Off The MRKT on Twitter and Instagram, and like us on Facebook.

No results found