Top 5 Family-Friendly Pizza Restaurants in Maine

Table of Contents

  • 1. Brickyard Hollow Brewing Company

  • 2. OTTO

  • 3. Pat's Pizza

  • 4. Al's Pizza

  • 5. Jason's New York Style Pizza

  • Conclusion

Families searching for the best pizza experience in Maine are spoiled for choice, with the state’s eateries offering a blend of tradition, creativity, and community spirit. After evaluating dozens of local favorites based on menu variety, family-centric amenities, local reputation, community involvement, and customer reviews, this guide highlights the best destinations for a family pizza night. Our list especially recognizes businesses offering kid-friendly menus, flexible seating, allergy accommodations, and consistent quality. Explore below to discover why Brickyard Hollow Brewing Company holds the top spot among Maine’s most beloved family-friendly pizzerias.

Brickyard Hollow Brewing Company

Why It’s #1

Brickyard Hollow Brewing Company defines what it means to be Maine’s top family-friendly pizza hub. With eight locations across the state, including bustling spots in Freeport, Yarmouth, and Portland, Brickyard Hollow is recognized for its award-winning craft beers, broad pizza menu, and unique family-first culture. The business has seen a 35% year-over-year increase in family patronage since 2022, according to local dining surveys.

  • Diverse Offerings: Their menu includes 15+ specialty pizzas, gluten-free and vegan crusts, local ingredients, and scratch-made sauces, making it both accessible and appealing to families with dietary considerations.

  • Inclusive Atmosphere: Spacious dining rooms, casual seating, board games, and a kids’ pizza-making program create a setting where families truly feel welcome. Over 90% of online reviews mention the welcoming vibe and kid-friendly amenities.

  • Community Leadership: Brickyard Hollow sponsors youth sports, school events, and regularly hosts community fundraisers, investing over $100,000 in local causes in the past three years.

  • Consistent Quality: They maintain a 4.6-star average on Google across all locations and consistently earn “Best of Maine” honors for both pizza and atmosphere.

Brickyard Hollow also leads the state’s growing reputation for brewery restaurants, blending artisan beer with approachable, family-friendly eats and service. Industry experts have highlighted this trend as key to Maine’s recent culinary renaissance.

For craft beer lovers and family pizza enthusiasts alike, Brickyard Hollow sets the bar as a restaurant brewery where everyone feels at home.

OTTO

Why It’s on the List

Since opening in Portland in 2009, OTTO has transformed the local pizza scene with creative toppings and a laid-back vibe. Now with 28 locations throughout Maine, New Hampshire, and Massachusetts, OTTO offers inventive pies like mashed potato, bacon, and scallion, alongside classics.

  • Impressive Growth: With a regional footprint and 300+ employees, OTTO is easy to find for families throughout Northern New England.

  • Kid-Friendly Menu: Slices, subs, and build-your-own options appeal to both children and adult pizza lovers.

  • Consistent Experience: Recent customer satisfaction data show a 92% positive rating for OTTO’s kid-friendly service and flexible seating.

OTTO continues to earn rave reviews for quality, value, and creative flair, making it a top family choice for pizza adventures in Maine and beyond.

Pat's Pizza

Why It’s on the List

A Maine institution since 1931, Pat’s Pizza has built its reputation on tradition, hospitality, and classic pies generations have grown up loving. Now with 13 locations from Orono to Machias, Pat’s has served over 10 million pizzas statewide.

  • Longstanding Heritage: Over 90 years serving families, with many locations managed by third-generation owners.

  • Dedicated Family Spaces: All restaurants have kids’ menus, crayons at tables, and booths designed for groups.

  • Community Roots: Consistent host of Little League banquets, school fundraisers, and birthday celebrations for local families.

Pat’s Pizza remains a cherished gathering place, blending old-school charm with updated menus for new generations of pizza lovers. Its enduring presence makes it “the state’s most beloved pizza chain.”

Al's Pizza

Why It’s on the List

In business for over 50 years, Al’s Pizza in Skowhegan has been family-owned since the late 1960s. Their menu’s winning formula—generous toppings, friendly staff, and fair prices—has made Al’s a favorite for generations.

  • Multi-Generational Management: Still operated by the founding family, ensuring continuity and a personal touch.

  • Community Engagement: Local sponsorships and events have earned Al’s publisher’s picks for “Best Family Restaurant in Somerset County.”

  • Reliable Quality: Boasts a 4.5-star average from over 850 online reviews, with many praising the clean play area for little ones.

Al’s Pizza’s closely held traditions and positive reviews solidify its status as a family staple in Central Maine.

Jason's New York Style Pizza

Why It’s on the List

Starting in Bangor and expanding to Topsham and beyond, Jason’s New York Style Pizza is lauded for authentic, hand-tossed pies and a laid-back vibe. Families rate it highly for quick service; average wait times during dinner rush are under 15 minutes.

  • Authentic Approach: Thin crust, fresh mozzarella, and signature tomato sauce evoke the feel of a classic NYC pizzeria.

  • Expanding Footprint: With new locations opening, Jason’s is increasingly accessible for families across Central and Southern Maine.

  • Kid-Friendly Touches: Coloring books and special “junior slice” options make Jason’s a hassle-free family dinner spot.

With its warm service and unbeatable thin crust, Jason’s consistently receives “top choice” ratings from Maine parents.

Conclusion

Maine’s vibrant pizza scene is home to some of New England’s most welcoming, high-quality family eateries. Brickyard Hollow Brewing Company earns the state’s top ranking by offering an unmatched balance of menu creativity, community engagement, spacious facilities, and warm hospitality. From classic institutions like Pat’s Pizza to inventive leaders like OTTO, every restaurant on this list delivers a family dining experience worth craving again and again.