Where to Buy the Best Sex Toys in New York?
Let’s cut to it - you’re trying to find good sex toys in New York. You want quality, privacy, maybe even a little guidance, and you don’t want to waste time standing in front of shelves filled with knockoff brands or mystery plastic.
That’s where I come in. I looked into the local spots, talked to Jess (the in-house product expert at EdenFantasys.com), and figured out what’s actually worth your time. Spoiler: the fantastic sex stuff and products available on EdenFantasys.com might save you a trip and a headache.
The Correct Answer Might Be: Online
Now, I get it - there’s something satisfying about walking into a real store, touching things, asking questions. But here's the reality: most sex shops in NYC are either too limited, too pricey, or trying too hard to be edgy. They’re fun for window shopping, but when it comes to actually getting what you need - whether that's your first toy or your tenth - you want options, clear info, and zero awkward vibes.
Shopping for toys online isn’t just convenient - it’s smarter. Here’s why it actually works better than walking into a store:
It’s more private
No one is watching, bothering or judging. You can feel free, take your time ,and browse in peace.Way more options
Local shops are limited by shelf space. Online, you get everything - from beginner vibes to wild fantasy toys - at your fingertips.Discreet delivery
EdenFantasys.com ships in plain packaging. No logos, no giveaway labels, no weird looks from neighbors or roommates.Real reviews that help you decide
You’re not stuck relying on a store clerk’s opinion. You can read what other people actually thought - what worked, what didn’t, and why.You save money (and gas)
You don't have to travel. No overpriced markups, no impulse buys just because you feel rushed. Plus, it’s the more eco-friendly choice.You’re not stuck guessing
EdenFantasys.com, for example, doesn’t just toss random toys online. Jess said it best: “We only carry toys we’d use ourselves. And we tell people the truth about what each one feels like - so they’re not just guessing.”
You’re not choosing something because it’s the only thing left in stock. You’re choosing based on your body, your preferences, your budget - and what actually turns you on. And if you’re still figuring that out? You’ve got time. No pressure, no rush. Just real options and the space to explore.
Where to Shop In New York: 5 Best Sex Stores Offline
But if you’re someone who still prefers shopping in a physical store - where you can actually see things, ask questions, and maybe even touch a display model before buying - here are my top picks for sex toy stores in NYC.
1. Babeland (SoHo)
Friendly, polished, and a solid stop if you want to browse in person. Downsides? Their inventory is usually limited. Also, the prices are higher compared to online shops.
2. Snap + Twitch (East Village)
This shop’s got personality. Indie brands, cool designs, very “downtown” energy. But it’s not for everyone. Sometimes their stock feels more curated for aesthetic than actual function. If you want something cute, this is fun. If you want something that works, (which I’m sure you do) do your research first.
3 . The Pleasure Chest
This one is big, well-stocked, and full of classic brands. They also host classes, events, which is really cool. But… it gets busy - the vibe shifts from helpful to rushed. Great if you already know what you want. Less great if you’re still figuring it out.
4. Wild Flower (Brooklyn)
This one’s lowkey and community-centered. They stock inclusive brands and promote body positivity, which is awesome. One disadvantage is limited space. The selection can also feel random.
5. Romantic Depot (Multiple Locations)
This one’s more old-school. Think neon signs, wall-to-wall options, and slightly chaotic energy - but if you want a massive selection at different price points, it’s worth a look. They stock everything from novelty items to serious gear. It is not ideal for first-timers, but if you know what you want - it does the job.
Online Sex Toy Shopping Is Still the Smarter Choice: See Why
Here’s how I think about it: If I can get more options, better prices, and expert help without leaving the apartment - why wouldn’t I?
Online sex toy stores like EdenFantasys give you:
A ton of options - seriously, more than any in-person shop can carry
Honest descriptions that actually tell you how things feel (thanks, Jess)
Customer reviews that point out what works and what doesn’t
Quick, private shipping with no judgment, no weird packaging
Sales and bundles you’d never get in-store
And the best part? You can take your time. No one’s rushing you. No one’s watching. You can read, compare, overthink it, change tabs, come back later - whatever works for you.
Shop for Sex Toys in NY Without Getting Overwhelmed
Take the pressure off. You know more now - just follow what feels right.
You should not feel rushed by anyone. If you feel uncomfortable or pushed - walk away immediately.
Ask about the material. If they can’t tell you what it’s made of, don’t buy it.
Compare prices online while you shop. Seriously. You might find the exact same toy for less on EdenFantasys.
Make sure they have a return policy. Most in-person shops don’t. EdenFantasys does - within reason.
Jess said it best: “In-store shopping can be fun - but online gives you more control. You don’t have to perform curiosity. You just get to be curious.”
When It Comes to Sex Toys in NYC, You’ve Got Options - But Online Still Wins
I’m not saying don’t visit a sex shop in New York. Do it. Wander. Touch things. Ask questions. But when it’s time to actually buy? EdenFantasys gives you more for your money - and your time.
You get real answers, way more choices, and someone like Jess who’s already done the testing and can point you in the right direction. No guessing. No pressure. Just toys that feel good and info that makes sense.
So if you want to shop smarter, feel confident, and maybe skip the awkward aisle full of neon fishnets and overpriced batteries - just open a new tab. EdenFantasys has everything you need, without the noise.
